20/April – COVID-19 Time varying reproduction numbers estimation for Brazil

These plots show the estimation of the instantaneous reproduction number for all the states in Brazil. These reports uses the method described in the work A New Framework and Software to Estimate Time-Varying Reproduction Numbers During Epidemics. We used the serial interval parameters similar to the ones used by CMMID with a \(\mu = 4.7 (3.7 - 6.0)\) and \(\sigma = 2.9 (1.9 - 4.9)\).

Note

This plot uses official data from government, reports until 20/April. This method is sensitive to changes in COVID-19 testing procedures and the level of effort used to detect cases. Therefore, changes in the testing efforts will introduce bias if the testing practices are not kept consistent. So please keep in mind these limitations, that are often not stated in many analysis around there. Imported cases weren’t also considered in this analysis, neither the delay of the symptoms onset and reporting.

Warning

Remember that this is the instantaneous reproduction number, therefore when it is below 1.0 for one or two days, it doesn’t mean everything is ok. This method is less sensitive to under-reporting but as long as the bias is constant. So please, read the plots with the limitations in mind. As an example, Portugal had an R(t) below 1.0 for almost 3 weeks before relaxing interventions, so keep in mind that it is not about being below 1.0 for a single day but for weeks.

Summary for the last instantaneous reproduction number estimate

Map for the accumulated cases

Map for the last instantaneous reproduction number estimate

Map of states with mean reproduction number R(t) > 1.0

Map for the accumulated deaths by COVID-19

Summary for the last instantaneous reproduction number estimate

Last update: 20/April

_images/estim_all.svg

Summary for recent median instantaneous reproduction number estimate

Last update: 20/April

The median R(t) estimates are clipped in 2.0 to avoid issues with the colormap.

Summary table for the last instantaneous reproduction number estimate

State Mean Estimated R (CI 0.975)
MA 1.15 (1.10 - 1.20)
PI 1.08 (1.06 - 1.10)
RJ 1.06 (1.04 - 1.08)
SE 1.03 (1.01 - 1.06)
RR 1.03 (0.97 - 1.10)
PE 1.03 (1.01 - 1.05)
ES 1.02 (1.00 - 1.06)
AL 1.02 (0.98 - 1.06)
TO 1.01 (0.98 - 1.04)
RS 1.00 (0.99 - 1.01)
GO 0.99 (0.98 - 1.01)
BA 0.99 (0.97 - 1.00)
SP 0.96 (0.94 - 0.98)
PA 0.96 (0.93 - 0.99)
PB 0.95 (0.93 - 0.97)
DF 0.95 (0.91 - 0.98)
PR 0.94 (0.92 - 0.96)
SC 0.93 (0.92 - 0.95)
MT 0.93 (0.91 - 0.95)
MS 0.92 (0.89 - 0.95)
RO 0.90 (0.88 - 0.93)
AM 0.88 (0.85 - 0.92)
MG 0.85 (0.81 - 0.89)
AP 0.84 (0.78 - 0.90)
CE 0.81 (0.80 - 0.83)
RN 0.80 (0.73 - 0.85)
AC 0.74 (0.69 - 0.79)

Summary for the Facebook COVID-like illness survey (last date)

_images/estim_all1.svg

Note

This is the summary for the Facebook COVID-like illness survey using the last survey date available for each state. Note that not all states have the same last date available, for more information please look at the plots for each state to see dynamics of these results and also the last available date.

Summary table for the Facebook COVID-like illness (CLI) survey (last date)

State Weighted Percent of CLI responses (95% CI) Sample Size Survey Date
Acre 7.52 (0.65 - 14.39) 107 23-06-2020
Roraima 7.18 (1.20 - 13.15) 111 14-06-2020
Amapá 6.79 (1.12 - 12.47) 101 15-01-2021
Rio Grande do Norte 5.22 (1.23 - 9.22) 213 18-04-2021
Distrito Federal 5.17 (2.43 - 7.91) 446 18-04-2021
Paraíba 4.47 (0.91 - 8.02) 198 18-04-2021
Sergipe 4.27 (-0.00 - 8.55) 118 18-04-2021
Espírito Santo 4.24 (1.34 - 7.13) 319 18-04-2021
Rondônia 4.04 (-0.06 - 8.14) 120 18-04-2021
Tocantins 3.39 (-0.42 - 7.20) 110 30-03-2021
Pará 3.24 (1.01 - 5.46) 332 18-04-2021
Ceará 3.22 (1.26 - 5.18) 431 18-04-2021
Mato Grosso do Sul 2.84 (0.41 - 5.28) 262 18-04-2021
Amazonas 2.83 (0.12 - 5.54) 208 18-04-2021
Maranhão 2.78 (-0.01 - 5.58) 188 18-04-2021
Pernambuco 2.32 (0.47 - 4.18) 368 18-04-2021
Bahia 2.24 (0.65 - 3.84) 449 18-04-2021
Minas Gerais 2.20 (1.18 - 3.23) 1246 18-04-2021
Alagoas 2.15 (-0.69 - 4.99) 130 18-04-2021
Rio de Janeiro 1.75 (0.85 - 2.65) 1333 18-04-2021
Paraná 1.60 (0.66 - 2.54) 992 18-04-2021
São Paulo 1.56 (1.10 - 2.02) 4244 18-04-2021
Santa Catarina 1.51 (0.18 - 2.84) 521 18-04-2021
Goiás 1.48 (0.18 - 2.78) 456 18-04-2021
Piauí 1.36 (-1.18 - 3.90) 129 18-04-2021
Rio Grande do Sul 1.20 (0.38 - 2.03) 997 18-04-2021
Mato Grosso 0.62 (-0.51 - 1.74) 287 18-04-2021

State: Acre / AC

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_ac.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_ac.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_ac.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_ac1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Alagoas / AL

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_al.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_al.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_al.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_al1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Amazonas / AM

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_am.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_am.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_am.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_am1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Amapá / AP

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_ap.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_ap.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_ap.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_ap1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Bahia / BA

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_ba.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_ba.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_ba.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_ba1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Ceará / CE

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_ce.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_ce.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_ce.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_ce1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Distrito Federal / DF

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_df.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_df.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_df.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_df1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Espírito Santo / ES

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_es.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_es.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_es.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_es1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Goiás / GO

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_go.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_go.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_go.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_go1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Maranhão / MA

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_ma.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_ma.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_ma.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_ma1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Minas Gerais / MG

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_mg.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_mg.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_mg.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_mg1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Mato Grosso do Sul / MS

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_ms.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_ms.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_ms.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_ms1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Mato Grosso / MT

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_mt.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_mt.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_mt.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_mt1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Pará / PA

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_pa.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_pa.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_pa.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_pa1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Paraíba / PB

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_pb.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_pb.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_pb.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_pb1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Pernambuco / PE

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_pe.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_pe.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_pe.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_pe1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Piauí / PI

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_pi.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_pi.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_pi.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_pi1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Paraná / PR

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_pr.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_pr.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_pr.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_pr1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Rio de Janeiro / RJ

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_rj.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_rj.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_rj.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_rj1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Rio Grande do Norte / RN

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_rn.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_rn.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_rn.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_rn1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Rondônia / RO

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_ro.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_ro.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_ro.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_ro1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Roraima / RR

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_rr.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_rr.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_rr.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_rr1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Rio Grande do Sul / RS

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_rs.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_rs.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_rs.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_rs1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Santa Catarina / SC

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_sc.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_sc.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_sc.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_sc1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Sergipe / SE

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_se.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_se.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_se.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_se1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: São Paulo / SP

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_sp.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_sp.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_sp.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_sp1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.

State: Tocantins / TO

R(t) estimate, incidence and accumulated cases



_images/state_to.png

Facebook mobility trend data for the state

_images/relchange_to.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Facebook mobility data. This data is released with a Creative Commons Attribution International license.

Mobility data for the state

_images/mobility_state_to.png

Facebook symptom survey for the state

_images/state_to1.png

Note

This plot uses official data from Brazilian government as well as mobility data from Google Community Mobility Reports. The red markers on the x-axis are weekends or holidays. This plot also uses data from the Facebook Symptom survey data kindly hosted by University of Maryland.